Report on grouse shooting shows its impact on biodiversity
Scottish Land and Estates (SLE) has welcomed research carried out by Scotland’s Rural College (SRUC) and the James Hutton Institute, which studied socioeconomic and biodiversity impacts of driven grouse moors as well as the employment rights of gamekeepers.
- Grouse shooting can generate significant economic impacts for communities;
- 60-80% of spending around driven grouse shooting happens in local areas;
- Driven grouse shooting has a higher employment benefit than other moorland uses;
- Gamekeepers and their families are key figures in their local communities.
Grouse moor management – including muirburn – delivers biodiversity benefits including a range of at-risk bird species such as curlew and golden plover.
Sarah Jane Laing, chief executive of SLE, said:
“This latest research by respected Scottish academic bodies underlines the importance of grouse shooting in rural areas.
The findings are definitive proof of the benefits – good for jobs, the environment, species conservation and attracting high-quality tourism to Scotland – all without being any drain on the public purse.
“The authors of this report urge that this work should be assessed along with three previous reports. Taken together, they show that grouse shooting provides multiple benefits that are in line with Scottish government policies. It is underpinned by private investment and not dependent on subsidies which are associated with many rural land uses.
“It is clear that grouse shooting stands up very well in comparison with other land uses and we should also remember that grouse shooting takes place alongside other upland activity such as sheep farming.”
The latest report looks at possible moorland use alternatives to driven grouse shooting, including “walked up” shooting where participants walk across the moorland rather than being positioned in shooting butts.
However, the report found ‘a shift from a driven to a walked-up enterprise would likely result in reductions in staffing and local economy impacts’.
Sarah Jane Laing added:
“Grouse shooting has been under intense and unprecedented scrutiny, particularly with the Werritty Review commissioned by the Scottish government.
There are indeed challenges for the sector which is committed to continuous improvement in land management techniques.
“However, we would urge government to take on board the overarching finding of this research – grouse shooting and modern moorland management in Scotland are precious and can make a major, positive to rural Scotland for generations to come.”